The Plaza 23 Diner

411 NJ-23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444, USA

About The Plaza 23 Diner

4.1 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Eileen Tuite
    -
    March 02, 2025

    Honestly, I have never encountered a ruder waitress than the one we had here today. Not friendly, very abrupt when asked a direct question related to a food allergy in our party. My daughter was brought the wrong dish and when we told her she argued, telling me, "I will show you the menu." Well, she did in fact tell us what the menu said and we again told her that the order was wrong. She was not apologetic or even polite, just downright rude. The food was all over the place. According to those who got them, the burgers and fries were good. Eggs and turkey bacon were undercooked. French toast tasted like straight eggs, the strawberries were literally half white and the whipped cream tasted like nothing. we had been here once before and had a wonderful experience, but after today we would definitely not return.

    Meriam El Mansour
    -
    November 18, 2023

    We passed a couple of weeks ago and had a couple pieces of cake and tea, we thought it was good so we decided to go back tonight to have dinner. The ambiance wasn't the best, l mean Friday night and most of the place was empty, maybe 4 or 5 tables with some old people, not a party! I ordered a philly burger and my bf a Thanksgiving dinner. The only server there never passed by our table not even to check on us, actually she spent most of her time sitting by the counter talking on the phone so the manager or owner or whoever that guy was. We were served by an old guy that wasnt even dressed as a server, he just looked like any other costumer there. Anyway, the burger was cold and dry went it came to the table, seems they had it ready before the turkey dinner and got cold, had to leave the bread cause it was hard and dry. We decided to order a piece of apple pie, the one we tried the very first time we passed by this place and to be honest, we found really good and tasty. Unfortunately this time the cake was frozen!! Even if we asked to warm it up , and they did, it was literally frozen inside. All in all, this place is a mess.

    Linda Ryan
    -
    November 29, 2024

    We went off peak time ... 200 PM ... so it wasn't crowded. The service was excellent. I had a delicious veggie omelet and my home fries were well done and crispy the way I requested. And it was less expensive than other diners. And same price cash or credit.

    Meghan Cahilly
    -
    July 27, 2023

    Came here for a late Sunday breakfast and it was so nice! The inside was decked out in pink for the barbie movie, and the staff seemed to know everybody, and even had a birthday gift for one guest! A real hometown feel where everyone knows each other and you're not a stranger for very long. The food was very good! The French toast was some of the thickest ice had in a long time

    Geraldine Bolt
    -
    December 22, 2024

    The food is always delicious, very friendly staff, a totally exceptional dining experience. I also have witnessed firsthand how excellent they are with the special needs community. I give them a five star rating If you are checking the other reviews on here, you Seriously, need to try them for yourself and make your own conclusion. I certainly did and I’m happy that I did

    The Plaza 23 Diner

    Our Address

    411 NJ-23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444, USA

    Get An All-In-One Marketing Platform

    Read More

    Faster Results Than Traditional SEO

    Read More

    Interested in getting more customers?

    Leverage Your Listing With Our Coupon Mailer!