My Bagel Heaven

220 Newark Pompton Turnpike, Pequannock Township, NJ 07440, USA

About My Bagel Heaven

4.6 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Naira Bourdeaux
    -
    September 10, 2024

    The bagels are ok, same as most of any other place, the service, however, is always terrible. You ask them the simplest thing JUST the bagel without anything and a cream cheese on the side and they manage to mess up even that. How is it possible not to be able to simply put a bagel in a bag? And be cautious, you will be overcharged. For the same thing they charged me between $5.57 to $9 dollars. When I mentioned that the cashier simply started yelling at me. Will never go back, rather drive few minutes more to Fresco's Bagels not too far

    Jill_thestylist_
    -
    September 21, 2024

    So rude, so so rude. And they made a Mistake on the entire order and when I asked them to adjust it after double checking they said I just work here it’s not their problem “ next” like you gave me the wrong order. I’ve been coming here my entire life they have changed for the worst with new management

    Sara Khalil
    -
    August 04, 2024

    My family and I love their bagels, that’s all we ever order from here. Unfortunately they don’t execute the order properly. We ask for toasted bagels and they don’t toast it. And on top of that I wait almost 15 minutes for 3 bagels and it’s usually not busy when I walk in. So I’m not sure what takes so long considering the fact that they don’t even toast the bagels. We are so tired of them not making our order correct so we will stop coming here

    Adeola Aina - Marshall
    -
    March 26, 2024

    I found myself in this area at 7 am, I was starving and saw trucks parked. If you see trucks , the food must be worth it. I stepped in and was greeted by a nice lady who took time to get my orders and had another guy serve me up. It was friendly, warm and the best bagel I’ve ever had. I paid $5 for 2 bagels ( plain sun dried tomato and scallion cheese onion)which is cheap to me. The reason for 4 stars is I thought they were a tad “greedy” with the cream cheese. I’ll sure visit again.

    Ted Dahmer
    -
    September 08, 2024

    Simple requests (asking for no ketchup on a bagel sandwich/toasting the bagel) are ignored. Parking lot is a nightmare and there is nowhere to comfortably wait for your food inside the establishment

    My Bagel Heaven

    Our Address

    220 Newark Pompton Turnpike, Pequannock Township, NJ 07440, USA

    Get An All-In-One Marketing Platform

    Read More

    Faster Results Than Traditional SEO

    Read More

    Interested in getting more customers?

    Leverage Your Listing With Our Coupon Mailer!