Everything about this place brings me back to my childhood. I always come in here when I come back home to visit. This is the essential Jersey pie. Sure, there all kinds of pizza available nowadays, but this is classic and perfect. Thin crust, just the right amount of sweet sauce to stick to the crust and allow the cheese to weld in place as well. Just as ice cream is always judged by its vanilla, pizza can only be judged by the plain cheese version. This is it. No embellishments needed. This is pizza perfection.
Kathleen McDiarmid
-
February 07, 2025
From out of town and asked what sub place was the best - this place was recommended and I'm so very glad it was - this sub is beautiful and warm and delicious- not to mention hefty!! 10/10 and if I didn't live 8 hours away I'm sure I would be a regular!
Chuck Mound
-
April 09, 2019
Very good slice of Pizza here. People were nice behind the counter. They have been making Pizza since 1969, so they know how to make Pizza for sure. This Slice worked well together. Everything from the sauce, cheese and crust was a perfect blend. Will rate well on the Pizza Hunters App in Morros County. I would go back again when in the area. Would like get a hot Pie out of the oven next trip.
Alyssa M
-
February 16, 2025
Such a great pizza for a just a cheese pie. Cheese was perfectly melty, crust was crunchy yet doughy. Did not expect it to be this good so had to write a review.
Frank V
-
December 13, 2018
Amazing cheese slices, buffalo chicken wrap was average at best. But the pizza was awesome
A lot of seating but kind of crowded i noticed 8 ovens so they just get slammed at times so all that seating may be for a purpose. Big fan will be back
Everything about this place brings me back to my childhood. I always come in here when I come back home to visit. This is the essential Jersey pie. Sure, there all kinds of pizza available nowadays, but this is classic and perfect. Thin crust, just the right amount of sweet sauce to stick to the crust and allow the cheese to weld in place as well. Just as ice cream is always judged by its vanilla, pizza can only be judged by the plain cheese version. This is it. No embellishments needed. This is pizza perfection.
From out of town and asked what sub place was the best - this place was recommended and I'm so very glad it was - this sub is beautiful and warm and delicious- not to mention hefty!! 10/10 and if I didn't live 8 hours away I'm sure I would be a regular!
Very good slice of Pizza here. People were nice behind the counter. They have been making Pizza since 1969, so they know how to make Pizza for sure. This Slice worked well together. Everything from the sauce, cheese and crust was a perfect blend. Will rate well on the Pizza Hunters App in Morros County. I would go back again when in the area. Would like get a hot Pie out of the oven next trip.
Such a great pizza for a just a cheese pie. Cheese was perfectly melty, crust was crunchy yet doughy. Did not expect it to be this good so had to write a review.
Amazing cheese slices, buffalo chicken wrap was average at best. But the pizza was awesome A lot of seating but kind of crowded i noticed 8 ovens so they just get slammed at times so all that seating may be for a purpose. Big fan will be back